If you’re looking for a luxurious and expensive getaway, you might want to consider one of the most expensive Caribbean islands. These islands offer everything from world-class resorts to private beaches and crystal clear waters. But how much do they cost? In this article, we will take a look at some of the most expensive Caribbean islands and find out just how much they’ll set you back.

The Most Expensive Caribbean Islands

The Caribbean is a popular vacation destination for many reasons: the white sand beaches, the clear blue water, the relaxed atmosphere. But for some, the appeal of the Caribbean lies in its exclusivity.

Not everyone can afford to stay at a five-star resort or villa, but for those who can, the experience is truly luxurious. From secluded island getaways to private villas overlooking the sea, there are plenty of ways to enjoy the finer things in life in the Caribbean. Here’s a closer look at some of the most expensive Caribbean islands.

A swimming pool at COMO Parrot Cay
A swimming pool at COMO Parrot Cay

1. Musha Cay, Bahamas

Owned by the magician David Copperfield, Musha Cay is the most expensive Caribbean island you can visit. In fact, it costs from $50,000 per night for 1 to 12 people to stay here, with a 5 night minimum!

But what makes Musha Cay so special? First of all, the island is incredibly beautiful, with crystal clear waters and white sand beaches.

There’s also a huge variety of activities on offer in the Copperfield Islands, from snorkelling and scuba diving to catamaran excursions and tennis. Plus, you can enjoy all this in complete privacy – the island is only available to rent by exclusive groups and can comfortably accommodate up to 24 people.

So if you’re looking for a once-in-a-lifetime experience and you have the budget to match, Musha Cay is definitely the place for you. It’s also conveniently close to Big Major Cay, nicknamed Pig Beach for its famous swimming pigs.

2. Necker Island, British Virgin Islands

Necker Island is an exclusive retreat owned by billionaire Sir Richard Branson, founder of the Virgin Group. Guests can enjoy their own private beach, infinity pool, spa treatments, and more.

Located in the BVI, Necker Island is home to a variety of wildlife, including pink flamingos, red foot tortoises, and rare rock iguanas. Necker Island resort is accessible only by boat or helicopter.

Guests at the 74 acre resort can enjoy activities such as sailing, windsurfing, and snorkeling.

Rates start at $5,150 per room, per night on a non-exclusive basis with a minimum of 10 rooms per booking, or $107,500 for your own private island. The price includes food and drink, as well as boat transfers and access to the island’s amenities, which include tennis courts, a gym, swimming pools and a private beach.

Necker Island is one of the most expensive Caribbean islands
Necker Island is one of the most expensive Caribbean islands

3. Moskito Island, British Virgin Islands

Spread over 125 acres, Moskito Island is another of Richard Branson’s luxurious properties. In fact, it’s just a few miles from Necker Island by boat.

Moskito Island has 3 luxury private estates which can be rented individually or as a whole: The Oasis Estate, The Branson Estate and The Point Estate. Rates start from $17,500 for one night at The Point Estate in low season.

There are also several communal recreational areas such as the Beach House with its bar, movie and gaming areas, floodlit tennis courts, beach and wrap-around pool.

Moskito Island
Moskito Island

4. Jumby Bay Island, Antigua and Barbuda

This 300 acre private Caribbean island is located just off the coast of Antigua. With its white sand beaches, crystal clear waters and lush vegetation, Jumby Bay, also known as Long Island, is the perfect place to relax and escape the stresses of everyday life.

The beautiful island is home to a wide variety of wildlife, including wild tortoises and Black-Headed Persian sheep. And for those who enjoy snorkelling or diving, there are plenty of opportunities to explore the colourful coral reefs that surround the island.

Jumby Bay is also home to a luxury resort, Jumby Bay Island – Oetker Collection. The elegant accommodations make it a popular destination for celebrities and high-end travelers.

Suites start at over $2,500 per night, while a villa at Jumby Bay Island will cost from $4,550 per night. Private residences at Jumby Bay are available from $10,800 per night.

Jumby Bay
Jumby Bay – Sakturner, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

5. Cayo Espanto, Belize

Cayo Espanto is a small island located 3 miles off the coast of Ambergris Caye in Belize. This exclusive resort is only accessible by boat, and its seven luxury villas are nestled among the palm trees and mangroves.

This Belizean private island is the perfect place to get away from it all and enjoy the stunning views of the Caribbean Sea. Guests can relax in their overwater Caribbean villas with private plunge pools, go for a swim in the crystal-clear waters, or take a sunset cruise around the island.

On the four acre island, guests can enjoy scuba diving, snorkeling, fly-fishing, spa services or take part in a bird-watching tour. Rates at Cayo Espanto start at $1,995 per night on a non-exclusive basis and include 3 tailored meals and snacks each day, personal butler service and transfers. Full island rental is from $15,995.00 in Summer.

Casa Solana Cayo Espanto Belize
Casa Solana, Cayo Espanto Belize

6. Parrot Cay, Turks & Caicos

Parrot Cay is an idyllic private island in the Turks and Caicos, offering a luxury retreat for those seeking relaxation and privacy. The clear turquoise waters and white sandy beaches are breathtaking, and the lush vegetation provides a feeling of seclusion.

This 1,000 acre luxury private island is a favorite among celebrities such as Bruce Willis, Donna Karan and Keith Richards, who own homes here. Parrot Cay is also home to an exclusive resort, as well as a beach club and spa.

There are several restaurants and bars, providing a variety of dining options. A stay at COMO Parrot Cay resort will cost you from $568 for a Garden View room and over $9600 per night in December for a 2 bedroom beach house.

COMO Parrot Cay Beach Club Deck at night
COMO Parrot Cay Beach Club Deck at night

7. St. Barts

Saint Barthélemy, or St. Barts for short is a luxurious island located in the Caribbean Sea. This French island is a favorite among celebrities and luxury travelers. It’s also one of the most expensive Caribbean islands to vacation on.

St. Barts is well known for its luxury hotels and villas, as well as its designer shops and restaurants. It’s also one of the most expensive places to stay in the Caribbean. Prices for accommodations start at $500 per night, and dining at top restaurants will cost you hundreds of dollars.

Among the best hotels in St Barts are Hôtel Barrière Le Carl Gustaf, Rosewood Le Guanahani St Barth, Eden Rock St Barths and Hotel Le Toiny.

St. Barts has many tranquil beaches
St. Barts has many tranquil beaches

8. Nevis

Nevis is an island in the Caribbean Sea that is part of the nation of Saint Kitts and Nevis. The island measures just 6 miles wide by 8 miles long.

The island is home to Nevis Peak volcano, a popular hiking spot. Nevis is also known for its natural hot springs, which are said to have healing properties.

Visitors to Nevis can enjoy the tropical climate and beautiful beaches. This island is home to some of the most expensive resorts in the Caribbean, including the Four Seasons Nevis. Nightly rates start at over $600 USD.

Four Seasons Nevis
Four Seasons Nevis

9. Mustique, St. Vincent and the Grenadines

Mustique is a small island in the Caribbean that packs a big punch when it comes to beauty and luxury. This private island is home to some of the most exclusive villas in the world, and its beaches are simply breathtaking.

Mustique is also known for its celebrity guests, who have included everyone from Mick Jagger to David Bowie, Princess Margaret and Kate Moss. Despite its upscale reputation, Mustique is actually quite rustic and unpretentious.

There are no cars on the island of Mustique, and the only way to get around is by beach buggy or bicycle. However, Mustique only covers 2.2 square miles so that won’t pose too much of a problem!

This private island is owned by the Mustique Company. Nightly rates at The Cotton House, start at $600 USD. A stay at one of the island’s luxury villas starts at $2000 per night.

A beach in Mustique
A beach in Mustique

10. Anguilla

Anguilla is a British Overseas Territory, known for its white sandy beaches and turquoise waters. The island is also home to several luxury resorts.

Visitors to the island of Anguilla can enjoy activities such as swimming, snorkeling, and windsurfing. Anguilla is a popular destination for both honeymoons and family vacations.

It’s also one of the most expensive places to stay in the Caribbean, with nightly rates starting at $600 USD. A villa at Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club will cost you around $1000 per night. Other luxurious places to stay on Anguilla include Cap Juluca, Malliouhana and Altamer Luxury Villas.

Island Villa Anguilla
Island Villa, Anguilla

11. St. Lucia

Saint Lucia is renowned for its natural beauty, including its rainforests, beaches, and coral reefs. The island is also home to the Piton Mountains, two volcanic peaks that are a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

This tropical island is known for its luxury resorts, rainforests, and beaches. It is also an important stopover for migratory birds, and it is home to the St Lucia parrot, which is the national bird of the island.

Today, St Lucia is a popular tourist destination, and its capital city, Castries, is a vibrant hub of activity. But despite its growing popularity, St Lucia remains a place where visitors can find peace and tranquility.

This island is home to some of the most expensive resorts in the Caribbean, including Jade Mountain Resort and Sugar Beach Resort, where a night costs from $529.

The Piton Mountains in St Lucia
The Piton Mountains in St Lucia

12. Barbados

With its white sandy beaches, turquoise water and luxurious resorts, Barbados is a popular destination for travelers looking to escape the cold winters of the Northern Hemisphere. Barbados is also one of the most expensive places to visit, with high costs for accommodation, food and activities.

However, Barbados island is worth the expense, and visitors will find that the memories of their Barbados vacation will last a lifetime. Barbados is a popular destination for golfers, with several world-class golf courses located on the island.

In addition to its natural beauty, Barbados also offers a number of cultural attractions, including museums, historic buildings, and art galleries. With its stunning scenery, amazing amenities, and rich culture, it’s no wonder that Barbados is considered one of the most desirable places to visit in the world.

A stay at Sandy Lane Hotel will cost you from $1000 per night.

Bottom Bay, a beautiful beach on the Caribbean island of Barbados
Bottom Bay, a beautiful beach on the Caribbean island of Barbados

13. Grand Bahama, Bahamas

Grand Bahama is the northernmost Bahamas island. This tropical paradise offers visitors a taste of luxury.

From the moment you arrive, you’ll be surrounded by stunning views of the ocean and pristine beaches. Grand Bahama island is home to a number of upscale resorts, restaurants, and shopping centers, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy the finer things in life.

Particularly popular for family-friendly Caribbean vacations, Grand Bahama is home to the ocean-themed resort, Atlantis Paradise Island, and The Cove at Atlantis.

Lucaya Beach, Freeport, Grand Bahama Island
Lucaya Beach, Freeport, Grand Bahama Island

14. Canouan, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines

This lesser known Caribbean island is part of the nation of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines and is situated between the islands of Grenada and Saint Lucia. Canouan boasts several pristine beaches and luxury resorts.

Canouan island is also known for its dive sites, which attract scuba enthusiasts from all over the world. The island is home to a variety of wildlife and a nature reserve.

As well as the ocean-view Mandarin Oriental Canouan, there’s the boho chic Soho Beach House Canouan for a slice of laid-back luxury.

A catamaran in Canouan, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
A catamaran in Canouan, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines

15. Bermuda

According to a survey by Numbeo, Bermuda has the highest cost of living in the world. Imported duties are costly and housing costs are elevated.

Despite the high cost of living, Bermuda is a beautiful place to live. This small Caribbean island is known for its pink sand beaches, luxury resorts, and golf courses.

Bermuda is also a popular tourist destination, so accommodation costs can be quite high during peak season. Among the best Bermuda hotels are Hamilton Princess & Beach Club and Rosewood Bermuda.

Aerial view of Bermuda islands and Gibbs Hill lighthouse
Aerial view of Bermuda islands and Gibbs Hill lighthouse

16. Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands

The third largest island in the British Virgin Islands archipelago, Virgin Gorda is known for its beautiful beaches and its luxury resorts. The most popular beach on Virgin Gorda is called The Baths.

The Baths are a series of granite boulders that have been eroded over time by the sea. Visitors can swim in the pools created by the boulders, or explore the caves and tunnels that connect them.

Virgin Gorda is also home to several luxury resorts, including Rosewood Little Dix Bay and Bitter End Yacht Club. These resorts offer a variety of amenities, including stylish restaurants, bars and swimming pools.

The Baths Beach, Virgin Gorda island
The Baths Beach, Virgin Gorda island

If you’re on a budget, try one of the other Caribbean islands that have a wider range of accommodations for all budgets. The Dominican Republic, Jamaica, Aruba, the Cayman Islands and Puerto Rico are all relatively inexpensive.

In Conclusion: Most Expensive Caribbean Islands

As you can see, there are a number of expensive Caribbean islands to choose from if you’re looking for a luxurious getaway. Visitors to these exclusive Caribbean islands can expect to find luxury accommodations, world-class dining, and a host of activities to keep them entertained. From sailing and windsurfing to golf and tennis, there is something for everyone.

Whether you’re looking for a private getaway or a place to host your next big event, these islands are sure to impress. So, if you have the budget for it, why not treat yourself to a once in a lifetime vacation on one of these expensive islands? You’re sure to have an unforgettable experience!

Do you have any experience staying on any of the most expensive Caribbean islands? What was your experience like? Let us know in the comments below! And, if you found this article helpful, be sure to share it.

Read next: The Best Caribbean Overwater Bungalows

Looking for more travel hacks and tips? From hidden gems to unique experiences, we’ve got you covered.

Join us on FacebookInstagramPinterest and Twitter.

Like this guide to the most expensive Caribbean islands? Pin for later or share with friends.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Sharing is caring!

Scroll to Top